Tag Archives: Robert Pickton

‘The killing has to stop:’ Canada’s missing women’s inquiry

National Aboriginal Day and Canada's deep wounds. © Deborah Jones 2016

Each Valentine’s Day the Women’s Memorial March is held in Canadian communities. It began in the early 90s in Vancouver’s Downtown East Side to honour, remember and protest the scores of women who have gone missing from the area, including the victims of serial killer and pig farmer Robert Pickton. Above, marchers in Vancouver on Feb. 14, 2016. © Deborah Jones 2016

August, 2016

“The killing has to stop,” said Nicole Robertson, naming the most urgent goal of Canada’s inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women (MMIW) at a panel discussion in Calgary.

Robertson, a Cree, won the 2009 Aboriginal Woman Entrepreneur Award of Distinction for her media work, and also has a daughter old enough to attract attention from the police as well as from men she doesn’t know. “I monitor how she dresses,” she said. “I scan crowds to see if a man is paying attention to her.”

“First Amnesty fought to find out what happened to 600 Stolen Sisters, then the figure was 1,200, and now the inquiry is saying the number is more like 4,000,” said diversity strategist Deborah Green, also Cree with a strong Piapot connection. One of the missing women belongs to her family.

“Thirty-four years ago,” she said, “the police came to my house and picked up my aunt. They drove her out to the edge of the city, in the middle of winter, and threw her out of the car. She froze to death, trying to reach a farmer’s house.” Such police excursions were so common they had a nickname: “starlight tours.”

The discussion was held two short days after the August 14 shooting death of Colten Boushie in a farmyard near Biggar, Saskatchewan, in disputed circumstances. So there was some tension in the air, mainly in the discussions around who should investigate the RCMP.

While the First Nations participants recognized moderator Jill Croteau as a media ally, somebody who is interested in Indigenous stories, they also asked her some tough questions. Robertson, another media specialist, asked “Jill, do you ever question what the police tell you?”

Croteau paused and acknowledged, “You have that default trust in authority. But as journalists, we’re supposed to be critical.” She paused again. “I didn’t really feel that shred of distrust until the Robert Pickton story. Sex trade women had told police over and over about this guy, and the police did nothing. They could have saved so many lives. I guess I feel there has to be accountability, and that’s our job as journalists.”

Green added, “There are other media too. There are Aboriginal media like APTN. And social media are powerful. Think, though. If four white boys drove a tractor onto a reserve looking for help and one of them got shot, what would the coverage be like?”

“The media are who they are because of who’s at the table,” contributed the fourth person on the panel, the Hon. Richard Feehan, Alberta provincial Minister of Indigenous Relations. “The families of the murdered and missing women need to have a voice, but not only them. Every community needs to have a voice. We need to start asking Indigenous communities, ‘Who does speak for you?'”

Feehan pointed out that the MMIW inquiry is the first truly national inquiry, in that every province and territory will undertake their own inquiry at the same time. He noted that the inquiry’s mandate is quite open and sweeping, including “systemic causes” and “historical, social, economic, institutional or cultural factors.”

They’re directed to examine the impacts of policies and practices of government institutions, including “policing, child welfare, coroners and other government policies/ practices or social/economic conditions.” The inquiry also has the power to call witnesses and to compel them to testify.

Four out of five commissioners leading the inquiry are women; four out of five identify as First Nations. The Honourable Marion Buller, Chief Commissioner, is a B.C. Provincial Court Judge, from Mistawasis First Nation, Saskatchewan. Commissioner Michèle Audette is a former President of Femmes autochtones du Québec (Québec Native Women’s Association), based in Mani Utenam, Québec. Commissioner Qajaq Robinson grew up in what is now Nunavut and, as a lawyer, works with a special 70-person Team North dedicated to First Nations issues. Commissioner Marilyn Poitras teaches law at Saskatoon, Saskatchewan and has shown a lifelong passion for First Nations issues. Finally, Commissioner Brian Eyolfson hails from the Couchiching First Nation (Ontario) and now serves as acting deputy director, Ontario Ministry of Aboriginal Affairs, Legal Services.

Richard Feehan pointed out that the Inquiry needed so much expertise because the issue was buried for so long and only came to light after First Nations families agitated and demonstrated and raised a fuss for more than a decade. “I want to thank the First Nations women and their families for their persistence,” he said. He praised the new inquiry commissioners for agreeing to serve on such a demanding team.

Globalfest panel members spent some time discussing whether the MMIW inquiry would really make a difference. They pointed out deep-rooted stereotypes about Native women and First Nations people generally, that have proved hard to clear away. Still, as mothers, Green and Robertson said they are constantly working towards the day when their daughters can be safe walking alone after dark, regardless of why they are out walking.

“Not in my lifetime,” said Green, “and maybe not in my daughter’s lifetime, but I hope someday Indigenous women will not be at risk for simply being in Canada.”

Indigenous women can’t do the job alone, said Richard Feehan. “This is a Canadian tragedy,” he said, “and if you’re a Canadian, that’s you. The commission can’t make the past disappear. It’s the community that will make things change. So come do your part!”

Copyright Penney Kome 2016

Contact:  komeca AT yahoo.com   Read more F&O columns by Penney Kome here


Government of Canada Launches Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, press release: http://news.gc.ca/web/article-en.do?nid=1023999

Related on F&O:

Canada’s National Aboriginal Day, by Deborah Jones

Time, some vast and today unfathomable sweep of time, may eventually heal the wounds in the people, families and communities left by Canada’s treatment of its first peoples; of even the theft, abuse and murder of generations of children. For now, on the first day of summer each year, Canada celebrates National Aboriginal Day.

Canadian Court Expands Aboriginal Rights. By Deborah Jones (archives, 2014)

Canada’s top court greatly expanded aboriginal rights in Canada’s westernmost province, in what may stand as a landmark decision affecting control of a vast swath of land and resources, in British Columbia and beyond. The case, Tsilhqot’in Nation v. British Columbia, was sparked in 1983 when the provincial government licenced a commercial company to log the Chilcotin. The licence was disputed by the Chilcotin residents who lived there long before the mid 1800s when — without their consent — England claimed the land as a colony, and named it British Columbia.

The Case of the Serial Killings: Gruesome details in Pickton pig farmer trial. By Deborah Jones. (archives, 2007)

Wedged between white-capped mountains and sparkling blue ocean, Vancouver is lauded for multicultural livability, ranked worldwide as a top travel destination and is preparing to host the 2010 Winter Olympics. But lately a grim pall has blanketed the western Canadian city of 2.2 million, for reasons far worse than the freak winter storms. The harrowing details of a grotesque serial killer case are bringing to the surface the city’s seamy underworld, usually confined to the squalid 10-block open drug and sex market known as the Downtown Eastside. The seaminess surrounds the trial of pig farmer Robert William Pickton, charged with murdering 26 drug-addicted prostitutes.


Reader-Supported Facts and Opinions is employee-owned, and survives on an honour system. Try one story at no charge; chip in at least $.27 apiece for more. If you value no-spam, no-ads, non-partisan, evidence-based, independent journalism, help us continue. Please share our links and respect our copyright.Details.


Return to F&O’s Contents

Penney KomePenney Kome is co-editor of Peace: A Dream Unfolding (Sierra Club Books 1986), with a foreward by the Nobel-winning presidents of International Physicians for Prevention of Nuclear War.

Read her bio on Facts and Opinions.

Contact:  komeca AT yahoo.com




Facts and Opinions is a boutique journal, of reporting and analysis in words and images, without borders. Independent, non-partisan and employee-owned, F&O is funded by you, our readers. We are ad-free and spam-free, and we do not solicit donations from partisan organizations. Please visit our Subscribe page to chip in at least .27 for one story or $1 for a day site pass. Please tell others about us, and follow us on Facebook and Twitter.


Posted in Also tagged , , |

The Case of the Serial Killings

The murders of dozens of women put Vancouver in the spotlight as gruesome details emerge in the mass-murder trial of an area pig farmer.
By Deborah Jones (for Time magazine)
Vancouver, Canada, January 26, 2007

Wedged between white-capped mountains and sparkling blue ocean, Vancouver is lauded for multicultural livability, ranked worldwide as a top travel destination and is preparing to host the 2010 Winter Olympics. But lately a grim pall has blanketed the western Canadian city of 2.2 million, for reasons far worse than the freak winter storms. The harrowing details of a grotesque serial killer case are bringing to the surface the city’s seamy underworld, usually confined to the squalid 10-block open drug and sex market known as the Downtown Eastside.
The seaminess surrounds the trial of pig farmer Robert William Pickton, charged with murdering 26 drug-addicted prostitutes. The trial, which an earlier judge warned would be “as bad as a horror movie,” began Jan. 22 and is expected to last a year. A jury will hear evidence on the first six charges of murder. (The remaining 20 charges will be brought to court after the first six.) Prosecutor Derrill Prevett described in his opening statement how police searching Pickton’s ramshackle suburban pig farm about 15 miles east of Vancouver in 2002 found two women’s heads in a freezer, cleaved in two and packed with their hands and feet. Human bones were found buried deep under an old pig pen. In Pickton’s mobile-home trailer, said Prevett, police discovered a gun and a sex toy with DNA from Pickton and Mona Wilson, one of the alleged victims.

“I couldn’t imagine,” said Wilson’s former foster mother, Norma Garley, nearly wordless. “Something like that happening to somebody in my family.” Garley and her family took Wilson in at age seven, after the girl was sexually abused by family members. When Wilson was 14 social workers moved her, but the Garleys kept in touch and Wilson telephoned them just before December 2001, when she vanished. Until the trial, the Garleys had no idea the girl they called “Running Bear,” the name honoring Wilson’s aboriginal heritage, had grown up to become a drug addict selling sex on Downtown Eastside streets. In her last call to the Garleys, Wilson told them she was engaged to be married and doing well, Garley sobbed in an interview with TIME. “Mona always wanted us to have a good opinion of her.”
The fates of Wilson, Sereena Abotsway, Andrea Joesbury, Brenda Ann Wolfe, Marnie Frey and Georgina Faith Papin are emerging in British Columbia Supreme Court, in the gritty Vancouver suburb of New Westminster. There, Pickton sits calmly behind bullet-resistant glass, an unimposing slim man with a fringe of lank grey hair around a bald pate. Now 57, he has become well-known in legal circles since his arrest in February 2002. But only now has the end of a Canadian publication ban, intended to ensure an impartial jury hearing, revealed the gruesome details of his case. Pickton has become instantly famous. “You’re like the pope,” a police officer told Pickton in a recorded interrogation played before the jury. Some 350 journalists are accredited and the trial is making global as well as local headlines. Each day curious spectators, including a class of teenagers from a local Christian school and several elderly people, jostle with family and friends of the victims for limited public seating.
The attention is new, but that Downtown Eastside prostitutes die gruesome deaths is old news, and largely ignored. Scores of women from that area have vanished since 1978. Only in 2001 did Canada’s national police force, then investigating a separate case of prostitute serial killings in the province, team up with Vancouver police. The joint task force now lists more than 60 missing women; police said the DNA, remains or belongings of about half of those have been linked to Pickton’s pig farm.
The missing women case has been the catalyst for a sea change in public attitudes to illegal drugs in British Columbia. Vancouver now leads North America in treating addiction as a health and social problem as well as a crime. It hosts the continent’s only supervised heroin injection site, as well as a clinic dispensing free heroin in a scientific trial. But not much has changed at street level in the Downtown Eastside. Some 15,000 injection-drug addicts, many of them mentally ill, are concentrated in Canada’s most impoverished neighborhood. An estimated 1500 female addicts continue to sell so called “survival sex,” at all times and in all weather. Reporters interviewing the women about the Pickton trial were shocked to find that many didn’t know about it, or care.
“Women who still live and work down here knew women who have died and gone missing,” said Kate Gibson, executive director of WISH, a drop-in center for sex-trade workers. “They are still out there working on the street, and they still face the same violence, stigmatization, and discrimination every day.”
Pickton’s lawyer Peter Ritchie says his client is innocent, and that he will refute the prosecution’s evidence. Pickton’s own voice is directly heard only in a videotaped police interrogation after his arrest and the first two charges were brought in February 2002. Played to the jury, the tape shows him mumbling and at times appearing barely cognizant of events. “I’m just a pig farmer,” Pickton tells police. “I’m a working guy, that’s all I am.” When told he was charged with two murders and was being investigated in the disappearances of 50 more women, he laughed. “Hogwash,” he said, slouched over a chair in the interview room beside some potted palms. “I’m nailed to the cross,” he said repeatedly. And when police asked if he killed as many as 50 women, Pickton complained: “You make me out to be more of a mass murderer than I am.”
As Pickton’s tale unfolds in court in a local suburb, the streets outside throng with police and sheriffs, panhandlers and patients released from a local mental hospital, college students and office workers who line up at local coffee shops. A stone’s throw from the court is a strip joint advertising, in neon, “Mugs and Jugs.” Nearby, a shop displays garish Valentine’s Day wares: a larger-than-life knight in shining armor standing tall beside a Queen of Hearts. It’s a costume shop, of course. Vancouver, in these dark days, has a dearth of real-life romantic heroes.

Copyright © 2007 Deborah Jones

Originally published by Time magazine,  January 26, 2007 . Read the original story here.

References and further reading:

Forsaken: The Report of the Missing Women Commission of Inquiry Volume I.
CBC timeline of the Pickton trial.
On the Farm, the book of the Pickton case by Stevie Cameron 

Posted in Also tagged , , , |